Hitherto unsuspected link between Agatha Christie and Anthony Trollope

Ricardo Jasso Moedano of Mexico City argues that there is a connection between Anthony Trollope and Agatha Christie. He believes that Christie took inspiration for one of her plots from Trollope’s oft-quoted decision to kill off his character Mrs Proudie in the Last Chronicle of Barset, following a conversation he overheard at his club, which he describes in his Autobiography:

“It was with many misgivings that I killed my old friend Mrs. Proudie. I could not, I think, have done it, but for a resolution taken and declared under circumstances of great momentary pressure.

It was thus that it came about. I was sitting one morning at work upon the novel at the end of the long drawing-room of the Athenaeum Club, as was then my wont when I had slept the previous night in London. As I was there, two clergymen, each with a magazine in his hand, seated themselves, one on one side of the fire and one on the other, close to me. They soon began to abuse what they were reading, and each was reading some part of some novel of mine. The gravamen of their complaint lay in the fact that I reintroduced the same characters so often! `Here’, said one, `is that archdeacon whom we have had in every novel he has ever written.’ ‘And here’, said the other, `is the old duke whom he has talked about till everybody is tired of him. If I could not invent new characters, I would not write novels at all.’ Then one of them fell foul of Mrs. Proudie. It was impossible for me not to hear their words, and almost impossible to hear them and be quiet. I got up, and standing between them, I acknowledged myself to be the culprit. `As to Mrs. Proudie,’ I said, `I will go home and kill her before the week is over.’ And so I did. The two gentlemen were utterly confounded, and one of them begged me not to forget his frivolous observations.”

These circumstances are mirrored in Agatha Christie’s novel Taken at the Flood, written in 1948. Poirot overhears a conversation in which the wish that a woman were dead was expressed and, shortly afterwards, she is indeed murdered.

It is difficult to prove whether or not Christie was directly inspired by the events described by Trollope in his Autobiography. She might well have been aware of the anecdote and she was certainly very able at taking things she heard about and putting them to use in her plots.

I leave it to you to hear Ricardo’s arguments and see whether you find them persuasive. (You can switch on English subtitles to help follow Ricardo’s argument.)

Only 5 more sleeps till The Bodies From The Library 2017

We are busy with the last few tasks to stage this year’s conference which takes place on Saturday. If we had a spare moment we would probably devote it to wondering where all the time went!

To put you in the best possible frame of mind to attend the conference why not check out our video “trailer”.


We’re really looking forward to seeing you all on the day, catching up with old friends from previous years and meeting new friends attending their first “Bodies”.

See you there!

The Bodies From The Library team

Security:

We are all deeply saddened by the recent terrorist attacks in London and Manchester. In order to protect visitors to the British Library where the conference is taking place, there will be additional security measures including bag-searches on entry. Please allow extra time on arrival to facilitate this. 

More suggested reading for the 2017 Conference

For those of you who wish to read up on the subjects of two more of our sessions at this year’s conference we suggest the following titles may provide an introduction to Edmund Crispin and Ronald Knox.

The Moving Toyshop by Edmund Crispin
Love Lies Bleeding by Edmund Crispin
Holy Disorders by Edmund Crispin

The Viaduct Murder by Ronald Knox
The Body In The Silo by Ronald Knox
Double Cross Purposes by Ronald Knox
The Footsteps at the Lock by Ronald Knox
Still Dead by Ronald Knox
Behind the Screen by  The Detective Club
The Floating Admiral by  The Detective Club
Six Against The Yard by  The Detective Club

CWA Dagger in the Library

Martin Edwards, in his capacity as Chair if the Crime Writers’ Association, introduced the long-lists of nominations for the CWA 2017 Dagger awards during the CWA reception at Crimefest in Bristol. The winner of the CWA Dagger in the Library award will be announced at the Bodies From The Library conference on June 17th. 

Illustrating Agatha at Crimefest

At Crimefest in Bristol and looking forward to tomorrow’s session on the Tom Adams covers for Agatha Christie’s novels. Our own John Curran has provided the text of the book which brings together in one place some of Tom’s most distinctive work. Tom and John will be interviewed by Jake Kerridge in what promises to be an illuminating session.

The Incredible Crime now available from British Library Crime Classics

incrediblecrime

Professor Kirsten Saxton will be speaking about Lois Austen-Leigh’s The Incredible Crime at the Bodies From The Library conference. The novel is newly re-issued in the British Libraries Crime Classics series (published last week) and is Professor Saxton’s recommended pre-conference reading for attendees who wish to make the most of her session.

To buy your copy direct from the British Library’s online shop go to:

https://www.bl.uk/shop/the-incredible-crime/p-952

(P.S. when we last checked the website it had not been updated to reflect the book’s publication on 10th May but fear not – the site may talk about pre-ordering but it is actually published and on sale!)

Final Programme Unveiled

We are delighted to confirm the final programme details for the 2017 conference.

10.00 Welcome
Martin Edwards – President of the Detection Club

10.10 The Continuing Popularity of The Golden Age
Martin Edwards, Len Tyler, Seona Ford and Jake Kerridge

10.50 Open Verdict: The life and work of Miles Burton/John Rhode
           Tony Medawar

11.20 Coffee Break

11.40 Lois Austen-Leigh’s The Incredible Crime
Professor Kirsten Saxton

12.10 Clues and Corpses
Dr John Curran

12.40 The Story of Classic Crime in 100 Books
Martin Edwards

1.10 Lunch

2.10 Radio Play

2.40 Neglected Queens of Crime: Ethel Lina White and Elizabeth Daly
Christine Poulson and Sarah Ward (Moderator: Jake Kerridge)

3.20 Murder and Music in the life and work of Edmund Crispin
Dr David Whittle

3.50 Break

4.15 Ronald Knox: Father of the ‘Detective Decalogue’
Dolores Gordon-Smith 

4.45 Desert Island Golden Age book
The speakers

—————————————

The conference will be followed immediately by:

5.30 CWA Dagger In The Library Award

5.40 CWA Wine Reception – to which all conference attendees are invited.

Advance copies of The Story of Classic Crime in 100 Books at special discounted price

51Ch8rqluPL._SX336_BO1,204,203,200_

Delegates at the Bodies From The Library conference in June will be able to buy advance copies of The Story of Classic Crime in 100 Books by Martin Edwards at a specially discounted price of £20. Martin will be talking about the book at the conference and, if you are persuasive, may be willing to sign your copy on the day.

Here’s what Publishers Weekly said about the book in its recent review:

“Written as a companion to the British Library’s Crime Classics series of reprints, this descriptive critical catalogue of 100 crime and mystery novels (mostly British) published in the first half of the 20th century is irresistible for aficionados and a reliable reading list for newcomers. Edwards’ picks, most published during detective fiction’s golden age between the two world wars, range chronologically from Doyle’s The Hound of the Baskervilles (1902) to Julian Symons’s The 31st of February (1950) and include, in addition to many of the usual suspects, a few outliers sure to enliven debates among diehard fans. He groups his selections into 24 chapters that cover numerous aspects of the literature—the great detectives, the fair-play mystery (epitomized by Ronald Knox’s The Body in the Silo), the miraculous or locked-room mystery (a specialty of John Dickson Carr), country house and manor murder mysteries, and so on—and whose ordering shows classic tropes giving way to newer approaches more resonant with modern times. A crime novelist in his own right, Edwards (The Golden Age of Murder) brings a specialist’s discerning eye to discussions of each book’s significance, and without giving away key plot points. This is an exemplary reference book sure to lead readers to gems of mystery and detective fiction.”

Do you need any other reason to attend the conference?

Sarah Ward joins Bodies From The Library Speaker list

NN1

We are delighted to announce that Sarah Ward will be speaking at Bodies From The Library this year. Sarah is the author of two DC Childs novels, In Bitter Chill and A Deadly Thaw (Faber and Faber) set in the Derbyshire Peak District where she lives. Her third book in the series, A Patient Fury, is out in September. On her blog, Crimepieces (www.crimepieces.com), she reviews the best of current crime fiction published around the world. She is a judge for the Petrona Award for translated Scandinavian crime novels.

Tracking down Agatha Christie at Greenway

IMG_20170413_162056387

For those of you of a certain age and a certain comic disposition, this is the sea view from my room at the hotel in Torquay where I stayed overnight before embarking on my visit to Greenway. Image taken without resorting to climbing on wardrobes, chairs or other items of furniture. It has been suggested that the finest view of Torquay is seen from the roof of the Riviera Centre on much the same grounds that the finest view of Paris is obtained from the roof of the Pompidou Centre.

The following morning I caught the steam train from Paignton on the Dart Valley Railway for Greenway Halt.

IMG_20170414_105807310

Along the way we passed the beach huts at Goodrington Sands which Christie used in her short story The Rajah’s Emarald, the only tale to feature both James Bond and Campion (albeit Lord Edward rather than his illustrious namesake Albert). “The beach at Kimpton is a long,  straight stretch of sand. A row of bathing-huts and boxes stretches evenly along it for about a mile and a half. The party had just stopped before a row of six huts all labelled imposingly, ‘For visitors to the Esplanade Hotel only.'”

IMG_20170414_104259379

Our journey continued to Churston Station, made famous as the location for the third murder in The ABC Murders and described by Hastings, reading from the ABC GUide as “Churston, Devon…from Paddington 204 3/4 miles. Population 656. it sounds a fairly small place. Surely our man will be bound to be noticed there.”

IMG_20170414_105030767

Once we had got off the train at the next station, Greenway Halt, we had a half hour ramble over the hill and through the woods to reach Agatha Christie’s summer holiday home, Greenway House.

IMG_20170414_112958298

Agatha, although she never wrote her novels while staying here, used features from the garden in some of her most ingenious plots. We therefore made our way down to the riverside and the battery, facing out onto the River Dart, which provided the scene for the murder of artist Amyas Crale in Five Little Pigs. “Mr Crale had been painting in a small enclosed garden, known as the battery garden, from the fact it overlooked the sea, and had some miniature cannon placed in embattlements. It was situated at about four minutes’ walk from the house…downwards through some woods…[He] was reclining on a seat and he was dead.”

IMG_20170414_113801846_HDR

A little further down the path beyond the battery we came to the boathouse, most famously the scene of the discovery of the victim’s body during a Murder Hunt in Dead Man’s Folly  at Nasse Housk, the home of Sir George and Lady Stubbs during a fete. “They passed the Folly and zig-zagged down the path to the river.  The outlines of the boathouse showed beneath them. Poirot remarked that it would be awkward if the murder searchers were to light upon the boathouse and find the body by accident…A short steep slope led down to the door of the boathouse which was built out over the river, with a little wharf and a storage place for boats underneath… [The victim] was playing her part nobly, sprawled on the floor by the window.”

IMG_20170414_114013927_HDR

In the same novel, “In a mood of exploration Poirot went through the front gates and down the steeply twisting road that presently emerged on a small quay. A large bell with a chain had a notice upon it: ‘Ring for the Ferry.'”

IMG_20170414_120029442

This ferry, though travelled in the opposite direction, featured again in the opening of Ordeal By Innocence in which “[Arthur Calgary] left to drive the seven miles along the crowded coast road and then inland down the wooded lane that ended at the little stone quay on the river. There was a large bell there which his driver rang vigorously to summon the ferry from the far side…He heard the soft plash of the oars as the ferry boat drew in to the side of the little quay. Arthur Calgary walked down the sloping ramp and got into the boat as the ferryman steadied it with a boathook.  He was an old man and gave Calgary the impression that he and his boat belonged together, were one and indivisible.”

IMG_20170414_120244832

Having thus explored Christie’s fiction we returned to Greenway House. Here we found a portrait of the four year old Agatha holding a favourite doll, which has survived to the present day and sits, somewhat unnervingly, next to the portrait.

IMG_20170414_125225033

More appealing to the musician in me, in the next room, was Agatha’s Steinway piano. Agatha played to almost concert standard but crippling shyness prevented her performing in public. Only her husband Max Mallowan was ever allowed to listen to her.

IMG_20170414_125327016

Although Agatha never wrote here, Max would use the holidays in their summer home to type up his notes from the archaeological digs he supervised in what is modern day Iraq. The tiny Remington Victor portable typewriter he used is in his study upstairs.

IMG_20170414_130400789

Agatha and her family were inveterate collectors and hoarders of stuff. Found hidden at the back of a cupboard were the insignia with which she was invested as Dame Agatha.

IMG_20170414_125537973

In an upstairs sitting room is a portrait of Agatha aged about 20, dressed in her finery to attend a social event at the end of the Edwardian era.

IMG_20170414_130554643

In the same room is a revolving bookcase which featured in Curtain: Poirot’s Last Case. “Mrs Franklin…was dressed in a negligee of pale eau-de-Nil and was lying on her chaise-longue. Beside her was a small revolving bookcase-table with the coffee apparatus set out.”

IMG_20170414_130508256

Though Agatha did not write at Greenway, she did correct proofs and, in defiance of any superstitious nonsense, did so in a favourite comfy chair in which she would sit during the sunny afternoons, down by the river in the boathouse. Which seems an appropriate place to leave her, having tracked her down to her lair in the garden of her summer holiday home close to the town where she grew up.

IMG_20170414_114406222