Wilkie Collins: The Lighthouse

Wilkie Collins wrote The Moonstone in 1868, arguably the first great novel of the detective fiction genre, which provided the blueprint – establishing the conventions, if you like – of the police procedural:fair play, concealing nothing significant from the reader that is known to the detective, etc. The Lighthouse is his two act play, written a little over a dozen years earlier in 1855, and itself based on his own short story Gabriel’s Morning, which he wrote in response to seeing the Eddystone lighthouse while in Cornwall. The story revolves around the reactions of three lighthouse keepers, trapped in the lighthouse for weeks by bad weather which has delayed the arrival of their supply vessel, to the involvement of one of their number in a crime some years previously which he reveals inadvertantly as his mind wanders in the delerium brought on by their desparate starvation.

The play was first performed by Charles Dickens and his friends in an amateur production at Dickens’s home, Tavistock House. The cast was Dickens, Wilkie Collins, Augustus Egg (the famous painter and regular companion of Dickens and Collins on their hiking -and other less salubrious – expeditions), Mark Lemon (founding editor of Punch satirical magazine), Georgine Hogarth (Dickens’s sister-in-law), Naomi Dickens (Charles’s eldest daughter) and John Foster, with Dickens’s son Charlie responsible for special effects such as the noises off for the storm. Although technically an amateur company, thriugh Dickens’s connections they drew on west end theatre expertise to support the production. The painted backdrop (part of which is reproduced above) measuring some 3 metres by 4 metres was by leading marine artist Clarkson Frederick Stanfield.

The play was performed on two nights, opening on 18th June 1855, plus a dress rehearsal in front of the family, and the 25 seats were over-subscribed. It is not clear precisely who was in the audience on these two nights but regular attendees at such amateur theatricals put on by Dickens included Alfred Lord Tennyson, William Cavendish – Duke of Devonshire, novelist Anthony Trollope and reformer Baroness Angela Burdett-Coutts. Reviews were favourable with Dickens and Lemon singled out for particular praise for their “display of passion”. Wilkie himself was thought to be somewhat less convincing.

The staged reading of the play on Saturday 14th October by the Speakeasy Players, preceded by an introduction by Jak Stringer, was the first public performance of the play for 146 years. The modern audience greeted this Victorian melodrama with enthusiasm, joining in with applause, laughter and gasps of horror at appropriate points. The dramatic climax of the first act, when the name of the ship foundering on the lighthouse rock is revealed to be the same as the victim of the crime all those years previously brought a genuine shiver down my spine.

Of course the world of theatrical drama has moved on from Wilkie’s gothic Victorian melodrama but this re-staging showed that there was a core of gripping psychological truth which he conveyed a century and a half ago that retains its power to grip an audience willing to enter into the spirit of its original production.

Barry Pike talks about Margery Allingham and Dorothy L. Sayers

Barry Pike gave a talk at the inaugural Bodies From The Library conference in 2015 describing the relationship between these two Queens of Crime, covering the parallels in the lives and writing careers. Now, for the first time, you can view Barry’s talk in full online either by visiting the Margery Allingham Society’s website where it can be found on the Allingham Archives page . Or you can view the video directly through the link below:

Barry Pike Bodies From The Library 2015

 

Ye Olde Book of Locked Room Conundrums

I am am currently carrying out research into Locked Room Mysteries and having gone to the usual sources: collections edited by Otto Penzler, Mike Ashley and Martin Edwards, I was very pleased to discover a new source for analysis. Ye Olde Book of Locked Room Conundrums, edited by JJ (of https://theinvisibleevent.wordpress.com/ ) contains fifteen stories, only one of which had I come across elsewhere. Credit for the selection of the stories goes to Tomcat (of http://moonlight-detective.blogspot.co.uk/ ) who has included alongside a Conan Doyle and Futrelle, one from L Frank Baum (creator of the Wizard of Oz), one from Robert Eustace (co-written with L. T. Meade) whose main claim to fame in Golden Age circles is as the co-author (with Dorothy L. Sayers) of The Documents in the Case and one from A. Demain Grange, who, bizarrely, is also responsible for an English translation of the libretto of Donizetti’s opera Lucia di Lammermoor (which does feature the death of a heroine but with little mystery as to the cause and culprit – in fact Italian tragic opera may rival crime fiction for the frequency of fatalities among female leading characters).

If you want a copy of Ye Olde Book of Locked Room Conundrums, then you can pick it up free at:

https://theinvisibleevent.wordpress.com/2016/10/29/15-ye-olde-book-of-locked-room-conundrums-publication-day/

 

A date for your diary: 16th June 2018

We are delighted to confirm the date for next year’s Bodies From The Library conference at the British Library. The conference will be taking place on Saturday 16th June 2018.

At this stage we can’t reveal details of who will be speaking and what topics will be covered but we promise to bring you the very latest and best in discussion on Golden Age Detective Fiction.

Tickets are not yet on sale but watch this space for notice of Early Booking offers.

Hitherto unsuspected link between Agatha Christie and Anthony Trollope

Ricardo Jasso Moedano of Mexico City argues that there is a connection between Anthony Trollope and Agatha Christie. He believes that Christie took inspiration for one of her plots from Trollope’s oft-quoted decision to kill off his character Mrs Proudie in the Last Chronicle of Barset, following a conversation he overheard at his club, which he describes in his Autobiography:

“It was with many misgivings that I killed my old friend Mrs. Proudie. I could not, I think, have done it, but for a resolution taken and declared under circumstances of great momentary pressure.

It was thus that it came about. I was sitting one morning at work upon the novel at the end of the long drawing-room of the Athenaeum Club, as was then my wont when I had slept the previous night in London. As I was there, two clergymen, each with a magazine in his hand, seated themselves, one on one side of the fire and one on the other, close to me. They soon began to abuse what they were reading, and each was reading some part of some novel of mine. The gravamen of their complaint lay in the fact that I reintroduced the same characters so often! `Here’, said one, `is that archdeacon whom we have had in every novel he has ever written.’ ‘And here’, said the other, `is the old duke whom he has talked about till everybody is tired of him. If I could not invent new characters, I would not write novels at all.’ Then one of them fell foul of Mrs. Proudie. It was impossible for me not to hear their words, and almost impossible to hear them and be quiet. I got up, and standing between them, I acknowledged myself to be the culprit. `As to Mrs. Proudie,’ I said, `I will go home and kill her before the week is over.’ And so I did. The two gentlemen were utterly confounded, and one of them begged me not to forget his frivolous observations.”

These circumstances are mirrored in Agatha Christie’s novel Taken at the Flood, written in 1948. Poirot overhears a conversation in which the wish that a woman were dead was expressed and, shortly afterwards, she is indeed murdered.

It is difficult to prove whether or not Christie was directly inspired by the events described by Trollope in his Autobiography. She might well have been aware of the anecdote and she was certainly very able at taking things she heard about and putting them to use in her plots.

I leave it to you to hear Ricardo’s arguments and see whether you find them persuasive. (You can switch on English subtitles to help follow Ricardo’s argument.)

Only 5 more sleeps till The Bodies From The Library 2017

We are busy with the last few tasks to stage this year’s conference which takes place on Saturday. If we had a spare moment we would probably devote it to wondering where all the time went!

To put you in the best possible frame of mind to attend the conference why not check out our video “trailer”.


We’re really looking forward to seeing you all on the day, catching up with old friends from previous years and meeting new friends attending their first “Bodies”.

See you there!

The Bodies From The Library team

Security:

We are all deeply saddened by the recent terrorist attacks in London and Manchester. In order to protect visitors to the British Library where the conference is taking place, there will be additional security measures including bag-searches on entry. Please allow extra time on arrival to facilitate this. 

More suggested reading for the 2017 Conference

For those of you who wish to read up on the subjects of two more of our sessions at this year’s conference we suggest the following titles may provide an introduction to Edmund Crispin and Ronald Knox.

The Moving Toyshop by Edmund Crispin
Love Lies Bleeding by Edmund Crispin
Holy Disorders by Edmund Crispin

The Viaduct Murder by Ronald Knox
The Body In The Silo by Ronald Knox
Double Cross Purposes by Ronald Knox
The Footsteps at the Lock by Ronald Knox
Still Dead by Ronald Knox
Behind the Screen by  The Detective Club
The Floating Admiral by  The Detective Club
Six Against The Yard by  The Detective Club